2007
- Best Novel (The August Derleth Award): Dusk by Tim Lebbon, Sprectra Books
- Best Novella: KID Choices by Paul Finch, Pendragon Press
- Best Anthology: Extended Play: The Elastic Book Of Music, Gary Couzens, Elastic Press
- Best Collection: Fragile Things, Neil Gaiman, Headline
- Best Short Fiction: Whisper Lane by Mark Chadbourn, BFS A celebration, BFS
- Best Artist: Vincent Chong
- Best Small Press: Peter Crowther, PS Publishing
- BFS Special Award (The Karl Edward Wagner Award): Ellen Datlow
- Best Non-Fiction: Cinema Macabre, Mark Morris: PS Publishing
- The Sydney J. Bounds Best Newcomer Award: Joe Hill
2006
- Best Novel (The August Derleth Award): Anansi Boys by Neil Gaiman, Headline
- Best Novella: Stuart Young, 'The Mask Behind the Face', The Mask Behind the Face & Other Stories, Pendragon Press
- Best Anthology: Allen Ashley, 'The Elastic Book of Numbers', Elastic Press
- Best Collection: Joe Hill, '20th Century Ghosts' PS Publishing
- Best Short Fiction: Joe Hill, 'Best New Horror', Postscripts #3 & 20th Century Ghosts, PS Publishing
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Best Small Press: Peter Crowther, PS Publishing
- BFS Special Award (The Karl Edward Wagner Award): Stephen Jones
- BFS Committee Founders Award: Keith Walker, Rosemary Pardoe, Phil Spencer, David Sutton
2005
- Best Novel(The August Derleth Award): Dark Tower VII: The Dark Tower by Stephen King
- Best Novella: Breathe by Christopher Fowler
- Best Short Fiction:'Black Static' by Paul Meloy
- Best Collection: Out of His Mind by Stephen Gallagher
- Best Anthology: The Alsiso Project ed. by Andrew Hook
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Best Small Press: Elastic Press, prop. Andrew Hook
- Special Award: Karl Edward Wagner Award: Nigel Kneale
2004
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Full Dark House by Christopher Fowler(Doubleday)
- Best Short Fiction: Christopher Fowler, “American Waitress” (Crimewave 7: The Last Sunset, TTA Press)
- Best Anthology: Stephen Jones (ed.), The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror: Volume 14 (Robinson/Carroll & Graf)
- Best Collection: Told by the Dead, Ramsey Campbell(PS Publishing)
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Best Small Press: PS Publishing
- Karl Edward Wagner Award(Special Award): Peter Jackson, for The Lord of the Rings
2003
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Scar by China Miéville,(Macmillan)
- Best Short Fiction: Mark Chadbourn, ´The Fairy Feller´s Master Stroke´(PS Publishing)
- Best Collection: Ramsey Campbell Probably: On Horror and Sundry Fantasies, Ramsey Campbell,(PS Publishing)
- Best Anthology: Stephen Jones [Ed], Keep Out The Night (PS Publishing)
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Best Small Press: Peter Crowther, for PS Publishing
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Alan Garner
2002
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Night of the Triffids by Simon Clark,
- Best Short Fiction: Simon Clark, 'Goblin City Lights'(Urban Gothic)
- Best Collection: Aftershocks, Paul Finch
- Best Anthology: Stephen Jones [Ed], The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror, Vol 12
- Best Artist: Jim Burns
- Best Small Press: Peter Crowther, for PS Publishing
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): No Award
2001
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Perdido Street Station by China Miéville
- Best Short Fiction: Tim Lebbon, Naming of Parts
- Best Collection: Kim Newman, Where the Bodies are Buried
- Best Anthology: Brian Willis [Ed], Hideous Progeny
- Best Artist: Jim Burns
- Best Small Press: PS Publishing
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Peter Haining
2000
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Indigo by Graham Joyce
- Best Short Fiction: Tim Lebbon, White
- Best Anthology: Stephen Jones [Ed], The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror 10
- Best Collection: Peter Crowther, Lonesome Roads
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Best Small Press: Razorblade Press
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Anne McCaffrey
1999
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Bag of Bones by Stephen King
- Best Anthology: Stephen Jones and David Sutton, Dark Terrors 4
- Best Collection : Ramsey Campbell, Ghosts and Grisly Things
- Best Short Fiction: Stephen Laws, 'The Song My Sister Sang'
- Best Artist: Bob Covington
- Best Small Press: Andy Cox, 'The Third Alternative'
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Diana Wynne Jones
1998
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): Tower of the King's Daughter by Chaz Brenchley
- Best Anthology/Collection: Stephen Jones and David Sutton, Dark Terrors 3
- Best Short Fiction: Christopher Fowler, 'Secret City: Strange Tales of London'
- Artist: Jim Burns
- Best Small Press: David Pringle, 'Interzone'
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): D. F. Lewis
1997
- August Derleth Award(Novel): The Tooth Fairy by Graham Joyce
- Best Anthology/Collection: Thomas Ligotti, The Nightmare Factory
- Best Artist: Jim Burns
- Best Short Fiction: Martin Simpson, 'Dancing About Architecture'
- Best Small Press: S. T. Joshi, H. P. Lovecraft: A Life
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Jo Fletcher
1996
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): Requiem by Graham Joyce
- Best Anthology/Collection: Andy Cox [ed], Last Rites and Resurrections
- Best Artist: Josh Kirby
- Best Short Fiction: Michael Marshall Smith, 'More Tomorrow'
- Best Small Press: Andy Cox [ed], 'The Third Alternative'
- Karl Edward Wagner Award (Special Award): Mike O'Driscoll and Steve Lockley, 'Welcome to My Nightmare' Convention
1995
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): Only Forward by Michael Marshall Smith
- Best Anthology/Collection: Joel Lane, The Earthwire
- Best Artist: Martin McKenna
- Icarus Award: Maggie Furey
- Best Short Fiction: Paul J McAuley, 'The Temptation of Dr. Stein'
- Best Small Press: Stefan Dziemianowicz, S. T. Joshi & Michael A Morrison, 'Necrofile'
- Committee Award: John Jarrold
1994
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): The Long Lost by Ramsey Campbell
- Best Anthology/Collection: David Sutton & Stephen Jones [eds], Dark Voices 5
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Icarus Award : Poppy Z. Brite
- Best Short Fiction: Dennis Etchison, 'The Dog Park'
- Best Small Press: Pam Creais [ed], 'Dementia 13'
- Committee Award: David Sutton
1993
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Dark Sister by Graham Joyce
- Best Anthology: Nicholas Royle [ed], Darklands 2
- Best Artist: Jim Pitts
- Icarus Award: Conrad Williams
- Best Short Fiction: Nicholas Royle, 'Night Shift Sister'
- Best Small Press: Stuart Hughes & Dave Bell, 'Peeping Tom'
- Committee Award: Michael Moorcock
1992
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Outside the Dog Museum, Jonathan Carroll
- Best Anthology/Collection: Nicholas Royle [ed], Darklands
- Best Artist: Jim Pitts
- Icarus Award: Melanie Tem
- Best Short Fiction: Michael Marshall Smith, ´The Dark Land´
- Best Small Press: Stuart Hughes & Dave Bell, 'Peeping Tom'
- Committee Award: Andrew Porter
1991
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Midnight Sun by Ramsey Campbell
- Best Anthology/Collection: Stephen Jones & Ramsey Campbell [eds], Best New Horror
- Best Artist: Les Edwards
- Icarus Award: Michael Marshall Smith
- Best Short Fiction: Michael Marshall Smith, ´The Man Who Drew Cats´
- Best Small Press: David Cowperthwaite & Jeff Dempsey, 'Dark Dreams'
- Committee Award: Dorothy Lumley
1990
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): Carrion Comfort, Dan Simmons,
- Best Artist: Stephen King
- Best Film: Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
- Icarus Award: Nancy Collins
- Best Short Fiction: Joe R Lansdale, ´On the Far Side of the Cadillac Desert with Dead Folk´
- Committee Award: Peter Coleborn
1989
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): The Influence by Ramsey Campbell
- Best Artist: Stephen King
- Best Film: Beetlejuice
- Icarus Award: John Gilbert
- Best Short Fiction: Brian Lumley, ´Fruiting Bodies´
- Best Small Press: Carl Ford [ed], Dagon
- Special Award: R. Chetwynd-Hayes
1988
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Hungry Moon, Ramsey Campbell
- Best Artist: J. K. Potter
- Best Film: Hellraiser
- Icarus: Carl T Ford
- Best Short Fiction: Steve Rasnic Tem, Leaks
- Best Small Press: Carl T Ford [ed], Dagon
1987
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): It by Stephen King
- Best Artist: J. K. Potter
- Best Film: Aliens
- Best Short Fiction: Dennis Etchison, ´The Olympic Runner´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales'
- Special Award: Charles L Grant
1986
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Ceremonies by T. E. D. Klein
- Best Artist: J. K. Potter
- Best Film: A Nightmare on Elm Street
- Best Short Fiction: Clive Barker, ´The Forbidden´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales'
- Special Award: Leslie Flood
1985
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Incarnate by Ramsey Campbell
- Best Artist: Stephen Fabian
- Best Film: Gremlins
- Best Short Story: Clive Barker, ´In the Hills, the Cities´
- Best Small Press: Stuart David Schiff [ed], ´Whispers´
- Special Award: Manly Wade Wellman
1984
- August Derleth Award (Novel): Peter Straub, Floating Dragon
- Best Artist: Rowena Morrill
- Best Film: Videodrome
- Best Short Fiction: Karl Edward Wagner, ´Neither Brute Nor Human´
- Best Small Press: Rosemary Pardoe [ed], ´Ghosts & Scholars´
- Special Award: Donald Wollheim & Elsie Wollheim
1983
- August Derleth Award (Novel): Gene Wolfe, The Sword of the Lictor
- Best Artist: Dave Carson
- Best Film: Blade Runner
- Best Short Fiction: Stephen King, ´Breathing Method´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales'
- Special Award: Karl Edward Wagner
1982
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Cujo by Stephen King
- Best Artist: Dave Carson
- Best Film: Raiders of the Lost Ark
- Best Short Fiction: Dennis Etchison, ´The Dark Country´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales'
1981
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): To Wake the Dead by Ramsey Campbell
- Best Artist: Dave Carson
- Best Film: The Empire Strikes Back
- Best Short Fiction: Robert Aickman, ´Stains´
- Best Small Press: David McFerran, Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Airgedlamh'
- Special Award: Stephen King
1980
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): Death's Master by Tanith Lee
- Best Artist: Stephen Fabian
- Best Comic: Heavy Metal
- Best Film: Alien
- Best Short Fiction: Fritz Leiber, ´The Button Moulder´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton [eds], 'Fantasy Tales'
1979
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever by Stephen R Donaldson
- Best Artwork: Boris Vallejo, ´The Amazon Princess and Her Pet´
- Best Comic: ´The Scarlet Citadel´ Savage Sword of Conan
- Best Film: Close Encounters of the Third Kind
- Best Short Fiction: Harlan Ellison, ´Jeffty Is Five´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales 2'
1978
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): A Spell for Chameleon by Piers Anthony
- Best Artwork: Stephen Fabian, 'The End of Days'
- Best Comic: Wierdworld
- Best Short Fiction: Ramsey Campbell, ´In the Bag´
- Best Small Press: Stephen Jones & David Sutton, 'Fantasy Tales 1'
1977
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Dragon and the George by Gordon R Dickson
- Best Artwork: Michael W Kaluta, ´The Sacrifice´
- Best Comic: Howard the Duck #3
- Best Film: The Omen 1977
- Best Short Fiction: Karl Edward Wagner, ´Two Suns Setting´
- Best Small Press: John Martin [ed], ´Anduril 5´
1976
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Hollow Lands by Michael Moorcock
- Best Comic: Savage Sword of Conan
- Best Film: Monty Python and the Holy Grail
- Best Short Fiction: Fritz Lieber, ´The 2nd Book of Fritz Lieber´
1975
- August Derleth Award (Best Novel): The Sword and the Stallion by Michael Moorcock
- Best Comic: Savage Sword of Conan
- Best Film: The Exorcist
- Best Short Fiction:Karl Edward Wagner, ´Sticks´
1974
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): Hrolf Kraki´s Saga by Poul Anderson
- Best Comic: Conan the Barbarian
- Best Film: The Legend of Hell House
- Best Short Fiction: Michael Moorcock, 'The Jade Man's Eyes'
1973
- August Derleth Award(Best Novel): The King of the Swords by Michael Moorcock
- Best Comic: Conan the Barbarian
- Best Film: Tales from the Crypt
- Best Short Fiction: L Sprague de Camp, ´The Fallible Fiend´
- Special Award: Robert E Howard
